When a couple is divorcing, one of the biggest questions is often, “what happens to the house?“ Sometimes the answer is to sell it and divide the proceeds; sometimes one spouse wants to stay and buy the other out, which may sound simple enough. However, it’s important to realize that a divorce real estate buyout involves a lot more than agreeing on a number.
You have to figure out what the home is actually worth, how much equity exists, what each person is entitled to, whether the spouse staying can realistically afford the home alone, and how the mortgage will be handled. And then there’s the human side of it.
When I went through my own divorce, my former husband and I owned multiple properties together, including our primary home and investment properties in other states. There were a lot of numbers to sort through, along with the emotion attached to those decisions.
At one point, I had to decide whether I should buy my ex-husband out of our home because my kids wanted to stay there. Ultimately, I decided not to because it didn’t make financial sense for me. After my own experience, I know how easy it is to look at a house emotionally during a divorce and lose sight of the bigger financial picture.
So, how does a divorce real estate buyout actually work?
What is a divorce real estate buyout?
A divorce real estate buyout happens when one spouse keeps ownership of the marital home and compensates the other spouse for their interest in the property. The basic calculation often starts with the home’s current value.
For example:
- Current home value: $500,000
- Remaining mortgage: $300,000
- Approximate equity: $200,000
If the spouses are dividing the equity equally, that would mean approximately $100,000 of equity for each spouse. The spouse who wants to keep the home would then need to compensate the other spouse for their agreed-upon share, but that does not automatically mean the buyout is $100,000.
The actual division can depend on the terms of the divorce settlement, ownership interests, other marital assets and debts, and other circumstances. That’s where your attorney and financial professionals come in.
My role as a realtor is to help you understand the real estate side of the equation:
What is the home worth?
What could it realistically sell for?
How does the current market affect the decision?
And, perhaps most importantly, does keeping this house actually make sense from a real estate perspective?
Let’s walk through the process step by step.
You may also be interested in: Expert Tips from a Divorce Real Estate Specialist
Step 1: Figure out what the home is worth
First up, you need to separate what the house means to you from what the house is worth. I know it’s often easier said than done. You may have raised your children there and put years of work into it, but, at the end of the day, the market value is the market value. And if one spouse says, “The house is worth $750,000,” and the other says, “There’s no way it’s worth that,” you need an objective starting point.
An appraisal may be part of the process, and I can also provide a comparative market analysis based on recent sales and current market conditions to help you understand the real estate side of the decision.
Step 2: Calculate the equity
Once you have a realistic value for the property, you can start looking at the equity.
Home value − mortgage and other applicable debts = equity
So, if the house is worth $500,000 and the mortgage balance is $300,000, there is approximately $200,000 in equity.
But the terms of your divorce agreement or court order may affect the outcome and the actual split. I can help you understand the property and the numbers from a real estate perspective, but you’ll need your attorney to see how the split is applied.
Step 3: Decide what the buyout amount will be
Once the value and equity are understood, the spouses and their attorneys can work through what one spouse will pay the other. Again, there are some complexities here.
- There may be other marital assets involved
- One spouse may be receiving retirement accounts or other property
- There may be an agreement about how equity is divided
- There may also be questions about contributions, debts, or other financial considerations
This is why I don’t tell clients, “Your buyout should be X.” Instead, I help them understand the real estate piece (the property itself, the market value, potential sale proceeds, and the practical real estate options available) so they can have a much more informed conversation with their attorney and financial advisor.
Step 4: Figure out how the spouse staying will actually pay for it
Agreeing that one spouse gets the house is one thing; being able to afford the house alone is another. If you’re staying in the home, you may need to refinance the existing mortgage or otherwise restructure the financing so that the other spouse is no longer financially responsible for the loan.
You also need to think beyond the mortgage payment. Can you comfortably afford:
- The mortgage
- Property taxes
- Homeowners insurance
- Utilities
- Maintenance
- Repairs
- HOA fees, if applicable
- Future capital expenses
Is It Better to Rent or Buy a House After Divorce? A Real Conversation for Single Moms
Step 5: Think about what happens if you need to sell later
This is one of the questions I encourage my clients to ask themselves: “If I had to sell this house in a year, would this still work?”
Realistically, a home is rarely a forever home. You may fully intend to stay for 10 years, but you never know what life will throw at you. Divorce changes things, jobs change, kids grow up, and financial circumstances change, so I don’t want someone making a six-figure real estate decision based entirely on what they want their life to look like today. That’s why I urge them to think about what happens if life looks different later.
You may also be interested in: 10 Tips for Selling Your Home During a Divorce
You don’t have to decide everything at once
If you’re considering a divorce real estate buyout, start by getting clear on the real estate facts:
What is the home worth?
How much equity is there?
What could it realistically sell for?
What would keeping it mean financially?
From there, your attorney and financial advisor can help you work through the legal and financial pieces. And if selling or buying another home becomes part of the plan, that’s where I can help.